Jordi González Guzmán
  • Inicio
  • Cosas escritas
    • Prensa
    • Académicas
  • Cosas dichas
  • About me
  • Contact Me
Jordi González Guzmán

Afterthought

  • Inicio
  • Cosas escritas
    • Prensa
    • Académicas
  • Cosas dichas
  • About me
  • Contact Me
Monthly Archives

abril 2021

Pierre Clastres
Investigación

Pierre Clastres and the anthropological riddle

by jordigonzalezguzman abril 1, 2021

Pierre Clastre’s seminal work Society against the State marked a turning point in the history of political anthropology. But this founding piece has brought much more into social sciences. Underlying his ethnographic reflection on the culture and political organisation of South-American societies there is a particular epistemological scaffolding that buttresses his ethnographic work.

Foucault assertively recommended Clastres book (vid. Les mailles du pouvoir, Dits et Écrits, 1981: 1003), as he saw in the French anthropologist work a compelling new perspective on how power is exercised, far away from a liberal -and Marxist- understanding of power. Foucault acknowledges Clastres new conception of power as a technology, a conception that aims to overcome the privilege of the law and the prohibition, which ultimately dominated the ethnological work from Durkheim until Lévi-Strauss.

Clastres unravels the cultural and economic features of South American primitive communities so as to shine a light on what does it mean to live in society politically and without a state. One of the features he is interested in is the institution of chieftainship, which is central to understand the political organisation of these societies, and therefore of power. The chief needs to hold specific traits such as the capacity to moderate and act as a peacemaker, an attitude prone to generosity by means of sharing all his possessions, and communication skills so as to perform outstanding speeches.

However, Clastres is troubled because the institution of the chief does not obey the rules that one would imagine after reading Hobbes’ Leviathan. The indian chief is not endowed with real might, rather the chief is only a by-product of the tribe or community’s might. Clastres points towards the chief’s lack of authority. The tribe or community function is to negate the power of the chief.

This is why Clastres asks: «Just what is this power that is deprived of its own exercise? What is that defines the chief, since he lacks authority?» This is the initial riddle that remains in all its mystery and the one which anthropology should adventure to grasp politically:

From where does this institution without «substance» derive its strenght to endure? For what needs to be understood is the bizarre persistence of a «power» that is practically powerless, of a chieftainship without authority, of a function operating in a void.

Pierre Clastres (1989 [1974]), Society Against the State, New York: Zone Books. P. 29.
abril 1, 2021 0 comment
0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail

About Me

About Me

Researcher • Writer • Reader

Entradas recientes

  • Toward a Criminological Understanding of Financialization
  • The Prohibition of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.
  • Informe: Impactes socials del mercat de lloguer
  • Pensant les classes de Seguretat Pública i Urbanisme
  • Pierre Clastres and the anthropological riddle

Comentarios recientes

  • Silvia en La encuesta inquilina: produciendo saberes autónomos desde Barcelona
  • Juan en Especulación en el mercado de alquiler: responsabilidad de las SOCIMI
  • Penci en Especulación en el mercado de alquiler: responsabilidad de las SOCIMI
  • Penci en La trama de las SOCIMIS

Archivos

  • diciembre 2021
  • noviembre 2021
  • julio 2021
  • junio 2021
  • abril 2021
  • enero 2021
  • diciembre 2020
  • julio 2020
  • junio 2020
  • febrero 2019
  • diciembre 2018
  • junio 2017

Categorías

  • Artículo
  • Criminologia
  • Docencia
  • Foucault
  • Historia
  • Investigación
  • SOCIMIs
  • Traducción
  • Uncategorized
  • Vivienda

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Instagram

Instagram

No images found!
Try some other hashtag or username

Recent Posts

  • Toward a Criminological Understanding of Financialization

    diciembre 9, 2021
  • The Prohibition of Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.

    noviembre 10, 2021
  • Informe: Impactes socials del mercat de lloguer

    julio 7, 2021
  • Pensant les classes de Seguretat Pública i Urbanisme

    junio 22, 2021
  • Pierre Clastres and the anthropological riddle

    abril 1, 2021

Categories

  • Artículo (2)
  • Criminologia (3)
  • Docencia (1)
  • Foucault (2)
  • Historia (1)
  • Investigación (8)
  • SOCIMIs (2)
  • Traducción (1)
  • Uncategorized (3)
  • Vivienda (2)

Popular Posts

  • 1

    A Genealogy of Militant Research

    julio 22, 2020
  • 2

    La trama de las SOCIMIS

    febrero 12, 2019

Quotes

Esto, desde 1966, no dejó de causar revuelo: (...) alors on peut bien parier que l'homme s'effacerait, comme à la limite de la mer un visage de sable.

abril 2021
L M X J V S D
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
« Ene   Jun »
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Email

2019 © Jordi González Guzmán


Back To Top